Skip to content

The Consulting Files: consulting case studies. The decisions. The money. The consequences.

The strategies that looked convincing. The incentives behind them. The people who carried the consequences. Investigative case studies for people who make recommendations for a living.

Explore the cases
The Consulting Files: The GreenSky Trade: A McKinsey Partner’s Insider BetThe Consulting Files: BCG, the GSA and an $860m Pricing Warning
EVIDENCE BEFORE CERTAINTY

Original documentaries, illustrated exhibits and practical analysis. We distinguish allegations, company responses and legal outcomes, then ask what a decision-maker can learn.

Open the files.

22 CASES · STRATEGY TO PUBLIC TRUST
The Consulting Files: The GreenSky Trade: A McKinsey Partner’s Insider Bet

FILE 22 · Insider trading & confidentiality

The GreenSky Trade: A McKinsey Partner’s Insider Bet

A partner advising Goldman Sachs on its purchase of GreenSky bought short-dated options in the target. The trade returned about 1,829%. It ended in a guilty plea and prison.

11 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: BCG, the GSA and an $860m Pricing Warning

FILE 21 · Government pricing & procurement

BCG, the GSA and an $860m Pricing Warning

A federal price list stayed open after BCG declined to show how its prices were built. The watchdog warned that an estimated $860m in sales could be at risk of overpayment.

11 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: McKinsey’s Canadian Contracts: The $209m Audit

FILE 20 · Public procurement & audit

McKinsey’s Canadian Contracts: The $209m Audit

Ottawa’s spending with McKinsey rose from under $3m a year to more than $55m. Three reviews asked whether the rules were followed. The auditors could not always say what the money bought.

12 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: McKinsey and Australia’s $6m Net Zero Modelling

FILE 19 · Policy evidence & procurement

McKinsey and Australia’s $6m Net Zero Modelling

Australia took a net zero plan to Glasgow without the numbers behind it. Part of the analysis had been bought from McKinsey, after the national science agency lost the tender.

12 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: McKinsey, China and the Pentagon: Serving Both Sides

FILE 18 · Geopolitics & conflict disclosure

McKinsey, China and the Pentagon: Serving Both Sides

The Pentagon was McKinsey’s biggest federal client. Chinese state-owned companies were clients too. Washington asked whether a firewall is the same thing as disclosure.

13 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: BCG in Angola: An Agent, a Declination and $14.4m

FILE 17 · Third-party agents & anti-bribery

BCG in Angola: An Agent, a Declination and $14.4m

A Lisbon office, twelve Angolan government contracts and an agent paid by success fee. The Justice Department declined to prosecute, but the profit went back.

11 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: McKinsey at Rikers Island: The $27.5m Violence Plan

FILE 16 · Pilots, data & public safety

McKinsey at Rikers Island: The $27.5m Violence Plan

A pilot reported a 70% fall in violence. An investigation later asked who was placed in the units, how the data was counted and what $27.5m bought.

12 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: BCG, Test and Trace and the £7,360 Consultant Day

FILE 15 · Public-sector fees & dependency

BCG, Test and Trace and the £7,360 Consultant Day

A £10m, four-month engagement became £28m paid. The real story is not one day rate, but how an emergency programme came to depend on consultants.

12 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: McKinsey’s $15m Bankruptcy Disclosure Settlement

FILE 14 · Bankruptcy disclosure & conflicts

McKinsey’s $15m Bankruptcy Disclosure Settlement

A sworn list of connections, an affiliated investment office and a rival who would not let go. What bankruptcy courts asked of McKinsey, and what they decided.

12 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: Bain and the Guinness Affair: Advice, Authority and Oversight

FILE 13 · Embedded advisers & takeover governance

Bain and the Guinness Affair: Advice, Authority and Oversight

A finance director on loan from Bain sat inside Guinness during a takeover battle. The share-support scandal raises a different question from the consultancy’s own legal status.

12 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: BCG and the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation: The Aid Model

FILE 12 · Humanitarian work & engagement controls

BCG and the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation: The Aid Model

A pro bono brief became several kinds of work. The firm’s own response describes missing approvals, a cancelled invoice and a separate reconstruction model.

12 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: McKinsey, Puerto Rico and MIO: The Debt Island Case

FILE 11 · Conflicts & restructuring

McKinsey, Puerto Rico and MIO: The Debt Island Case

A restructuring adviser, an affiliated investment office and the question of what an information barrier really separates.

12 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: The McKinsey Affair in France: Spending, Tax and Trust

FILE 10 · Public money & transparency

The McKinsey Affair in France: Spending, Tax and Trust

A Senate inquiry into government consulting became a test of transparency. Several investigations followed, with different questions and outcomes.

11 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: McKinsey and ICE: Who Carries the Cost of a Saving?

FILE 09 · Cost & public duty

McKinsey and ICE: Who Carries the Cost of a Saving?

A detention-cost project exposes the difference between an accounting saving and a defensible public-service outcome.

11 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: McKinsey’s Saudi Arabia Report: The Risk of Naming Names

FILE 08 · Research & downstream harm

McKinsey’s Saudi Arabia Report: The Risk of Naming Names

A short social-media analysis raised a larger question: what responsibilities follow when ordinary research identifies vulnerable people?

10 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: Allstate and McKinsey: Good Hands or Boxing Gloves?

FILE 07 · Metrics & customer fairness

Allstate and McKinsey: Good Hands or Boxing Gloves?

A claims-transformation programme became a dispute about fairness, software, documents and the promises an insurer makes.

11 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: Luanda Leaks: The Consultants and Angola’s Oil Money

FILE 06 · Money flows & due diligence

Luanda Leaks: The Consultants and Angola’s Oil Money

The contract, the invoice and the beneficiary were not always the same thing. Following the payment chain changes the story.

11 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: McKinsey, Bain and South Africa’s State Capture

FILE 05 · Institutions & procurement

McKinsey, Bain and South Africa’s State Capture

An electricity company, a freight network and a tax authority reveal different ways that institutional safeguards can fail.

11 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: McKinsey, Purdue and the Opioid Crisis: A Strategy Case

FILE 04 · Growth & responsibility

McKinsey, Purdue and the Opioid Crisis: A Strategy Case

What happens when an ordinary sales-growth toolkit is applied to a product with extraordinary risks?

11 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: Enron, McKinsey and the Limits of the War for Talent

FILE 03 · Incentives & control

Enron, McKinsey and the Limits of the War for Talent

Enron hired exceptional people and celebrated exceptional results. Its systems failed to distinguish performance from the appearance of performance.

10 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: Rajat Gupta’s Insider Trading Case: When Trust Broke

FILE 02 · Trust & confidentiality

Rajat Gupta’s Insider Trading Case: When Trust Broke

The former McKinsey leader reached the most powerful boardrooms in business. A series of calls became evidence against him.

10 MIN READRead the case
The Consulting Files: Why Swissair Failed: The Hunter Strategy, Explained

FILE 01 · Strategy & liquidity

Why Swissair Failed: The Hunter Strategy, Explained

An airline known as the flying bank bought a network of troubled carriers. The map grew. The cash ran out.

10 MIN READRead the case

PUT THE THINKING TO WORK

Good slides start with better questions.

Explore the evidence behind our six-tool AI presentation benchmark, or turn a well-supported recommendation into an editable business deck.

See the AI tool test